The Constitution and the wisdom of the Founding Fathers

By Dale E. Landrith Sr. | Jan 02, 2020

I am not sure that many folks today understand the wisdom of those men of more than two centuries ago who wrote our United States Constitution. People seem confused or have no knowledge about what is going on in our government today. The emotion of the moment seems to be more important than the “why” of how the government functions.

There is a common thread in this confusion. Why are the representatives in the House of Representatives elected to shorter terms and more frequently than the senators in the Senate? Why is there an Electoral College? Why are there three co-equal branches of our government?

Basic public education in times gone by instilled this information in students before they entered into adulthood and began participating in the electoral process. I am not so sure that this happens today.

Why are the representatives in the House of Representatives elected to shorter terms than the senators in the Senate? The House of Representatives is to be the “people’s house.” It is to be a reflection of the general population of the country. The short two-year terms are so that as the views of the voters change the representation in the House will change to reflect that on a frequent basis.

The Senate is not designed to be a representation of the general population, but is to be a representation of the states. Two senators are elected from each state. The senatorial election process was changed by amendment but the design remains the same, as senators are elected from each state to six-year terms with the terms staggered so that one third of the total number of senators are elected every two years .

The wisdom of this design is currently on display in the impeachment process of our current president. A totally partisan display of power has resulted in a vote to impeach President Trump by the House of Representatives. Due process was completely ignored and much of this process was carried out in complete secrecy by the Democrats. The Democrats successfully voted in a totally partisan manner for impeachment. However, the process must be completed in the Senate.

The Senate is controlled by Republicans and the House Democrats seem to now realize that the Senate is also capable of a completely partisan trial. This is exactly what the Founding Fathers wanted to avoid. By making the process difficult, they thought that impeachment would be rare and for such extraordinary offenses that partisanship would be laid aside.

Why is there an Electoral College? In the colonial United States there were some relatively large cities and much of the rest of the country was rural. As the United States matured, the development of our demographics has remained remarkably similar. We have numerous large cities and much of the country is rural. The founding fathers did not want the highly populated cities and/or states to rule the country at the expense of the less populated areas.

Much has been made of the fact that President Trump did not gain the majority of the popular vote in the 2016 election. However, the loss of the popular vote was 100% due to the voting in the New York City area, the Los Angeles area, and other large cities. The foresight of the founders was accurate in that they did not want the country dominated by just the big cities.

Let us remember that one of America’s greatest presidents, Abraham Lincoln, only received roughly 40% of the popular vote and yet became president because of the Electoral College.

Why are there three co-equal branches of government? The founding fathers understood that, from the beginning of civilization, humankind has always had a quest for more and more power. In our governmental system, Congress alone cannot dictate new law, as the president must agree. If the president does not agree, then his veto must be overridden by a supermajority in the House of Representatives and the Senate before it can become law. If the Congress and the president agree on a law and the general public finds the law onerous, then the public may petition the courts for relief and the courts may choose to nullify the law.

All of this is designed so that out-of-control raw power can be held in check. Consensus and gridlock were built into the system and they are formally called “checks and balances.”

Before condemning the process, Americans should take time to understand the wisdom behind the dictates of the Constitution.

If you appreciated reading this news story and want to support local journalism, consider subscribing today.
Call (207) 594-4401 or join online at waldo.villagesoup.com/join.
Donate directly to keeping quality journalism alive at waldo.villagesoup.com/donate.
Comments (4)
Posted by: Stephen J. Melchiskey | Jan 08, 2020 17:20

Wow, regardless of if you realize it or not, Ron both eviscerated and excoriated your arguments in one fell swoop. I often wonder how it feels when the various so called “Concerned Citizens “ are faced with their twisted reasoning and bases being exposed.



Posted by: Dale E. Landrith Sr. | Jan 08, 2020 10:37

Ron

I do happen to have a hard copy of the Federalist Papers and to research them.  Do you?  In addition look up "Clinton Impeachment" on Wikipedia.  Ken Starr was appointed by a Democrat Attorney General, Janet Reno and the entire process was orderly and very non-partisan.



Posted by: Francis Mazzeo, Jr. | Jan 02, 2020 12:44

Not knowing the constitution has nothing to do with a bunch of dishonest politicians. Most people realize that greed has overridden any sense of fairness. It seems the more educated and wealthy one becomes, the less they care about anyone but themselves. Write a column about some poor working stiff trying enjoy living on substandard wages. People that have never gone without should not dictate to the masses.

 



Posted by: Dale E. Landrith Sr. | Jan 02, 2020 12:13

Ron

Once again a nice job of ignoring the premise of the entire article.  I also think your claim about the Republicans and the Clinton impeachment is either completely off base or ignores the differences in the process at the time.  However, I hope to do a little research and come back to this.



If you wish to comment, please login.