Waldo County Republican legislators help sustain veterans' health access veto

REAL ID compliance bill passes
By Jordan Bailey | Apr 10, 2017
Photo by: Jordan Bailey

The Maine House of Representatives on April 4 failed to override a governor’s veto on a bill that would have helped veterans who have been barred from accessing medical care because of Maine’s non-compliance with federal REAL ID laws. All of Waldo County’s representatives had originally supported the bill but none of the Republican representatives in the county supported it in the override vote.

The bill would have provided passport cards at a one-time-cost of $15,000 to the approximately 500 veterans who receive medical services at Pease Air Force Base in New Hampshire. The base no longer accepts Maine driver’s licenses as identification.

An Act To Provide Funds for Access for Veterans Seeking Health Care, LD 213, passed the House March 14 with a vote of 110-8. It passed the Senate unanimously March 21, and was vetoed by the governor March 30.

“Though I agree with the sentiment to help veterans seeking medical care, we cannot forget all the other groups that have experienced problems due to REAL ID,” Governor Paul LePage wrote in his veto letter. “I respectfully urge the Legislature to not provide case-by-case carve outs for groups being effected (sic) by REAL ID.”

Instead he asked legislators to back LD 306, which would bring Maine into full compliance with federal REAL ID laws, a more controversial proposal because of privacy concerns and the cost of compliance, estimated to be approximately $3 million.

During testimony for LD 306, 10 people spoke in support of the bill, including representatives of contractors', carpenters' and truckers' unions, and 10 spoke against it, including Secretary of State Matthew Dunlap and representatives of the American Civil Liberties Union of Maine.

Maine democrats reacted to the veto of LD 213 in a press release: “We can't understand why the Governor endangered veterans to make a political point. Governor LePage is trying to use Maine's veterans as political pawns, and risking their health in the process."

Some have argued that while the REAL ID bill is being debated, and, if it passes, until it is implemented, the 500 veterans affected by LD 213 will not have access to medical care.

Republican representatives Karl Ward of Dedham and James Gillway of Searsport honored LePage’s request and voted against the override April 4. Rep. Maryanne Kinney, R-Knox, was absent. Democratic Representatives Erin Herbig of Belfast and Stanley Paige Zeigler of Montville voted for the override.

The override needed 96 votes to pass, but failed by 7 votes with 89 for and 54 against.

The same day, LD 306, the bill which would bring Maine into full compliance with federal REAL ID laws, passed the Senate by a vote of 31-4. Thibodeau voted for the bill.

On April 11, members of the House passed the measure, 115-30. All Waldo County representatives voted in favor of the bill, with the exception of Rep. Owen Casas, I-Rockport, who represents Islesboro.

Editor's note: This story was updated April 11 to reflect passage of LD 306.

Comments (6)
Posted by: Peter Petersen | Apr 13, 2017 16:53

new bill passed today


Posted by: Peter Petersen | Apr 13, 2017 16:51

The vets already have a bypass way to access facilities.  Congrats to our legislators for passing to a bill to correct this issue for ALL Mainers! Now we won't have to worry about carrying our passports for USA travel, and there is even an opt out provision for those concerned about privacy.  Let's congratulate all our hard working legislators for getting the job done! Maybe you all at the Press can do full research before jumping the gun and printing one sided headlines; after all there are some of us who read more than just the headline.


Posted by: Patricia Keyes | Apr 12, 2017 15:29

Let's don't forget!  You can board an airplane with YOUR PASSPORT!

Posted by: Patricia Keyes | Apr 12, 2017 15:28

If the Democrats want to help veterans, they'd CLOSE the VA, cut the cost of buildings, employees, and office supplies, and they'd simply pay for veterans to go to the doctor of their choice in their own neighborhoods!

Government simply cannot make daily personal decisions for millions of people! It is NOT cost efficient to hire staff to assume responsibility for choices only you can make and be happy with! Single payer government run healthcare is a joke!

Posted by: Patricia Keyes | Apr 11, 2017 15:54

Why no national ID in Maine?  Here's a LONG historical list of why no state should have participated in creating this theft of our freedom.

Posted by: Patricia Keyes | Apr 11, 2017 15:54

It's easy to understand the Governor's reasoning! It's stated in this report!  Governor LePage rightly understands that laws should apply to everyone equally, and it is a very bad move to start making "carve outs" or SPECIAL PRIVILEGES for special small groups. It's discriminatory!  The Dems would love that! Then they could use it as a legal precedent for shoving all sorts of silly exceptions on any number of subjects until nobody know what in the world is going on!

It is extremely disingenuous of the Democrats in the legislature to fein concern for our veterans. If they cared about veterans, they would have ended the failed single-provider government-run healthcare system that is the VA, and they would simply let vets use the doctors of their choice!

If you wish to comment, please login.

Staff Profile

Jordan M Bailey
207-338-3333 ext. 109
Email Me

Jordan Bailey has been working for The Republican Journal since 2013. She studied philosophy at Boston College and has experience in marine science education and journalism. She lives in Belfast.


Recent Stories by Jordan M Bailey